New Worlds: Unconventional Goals
Up front, I’ll admit that the title of this week’s essay is a little misleading. Some of the military goals I’m going to discuss here aren’t actually unconventional; they’re a perfectly normal part of warfare, especially in the past. They are, however, not necessarily what people imagine when warfare comes to mind. The layperson tends to think in terms of two goals: kill the enemy soldiers, and take over the enemy’s land. Neither of which is wrong . . . but they’re not the whole story, and even what those two look like may not be what people assume.
Let’s start with killing soldiers. Yes, this is usually a part of warfare — but not all the soldiers. Historically speaking, it’s a rare battle that results in a massacre, with the majority of the opposing force dead right there on the field. More often, a battle ends when one side “breaks” and attempts to flee, preferably (from the perspective of the victor) as individuals running for their lives, not as a coherent unit that might regroup and come back to cause trouble later. Or they surrender — and that one’s great because now it means you have captives.
Captives are an extremely common goal in historical warfare! They’re a great resource to have, whether you obtain them through surrender, through rounding up those who fled, through overrunning a civilian population, or through some other method. If your society has slavery, as many in the past did, there you go: a fresh supply of slaves. Getting those slaves might even be the reason for the war, especially if it’s a matter of raiding into enemy territory rather than facing down an opposing army. Alternatively, you can hold your more important captives for ransom — this was a common feature of medieval European warfare — or trade them for your own people held captive on the other side, as in modern exchanges of prisoners of war. More gruesomely, if your society practices human sacrifice, those captives are prizes you can offer up to your gods.
What about land? Yes, often the goal is indeed to occupy it and make it part of your realm. But what does that entail? Do you have to kill or drive off everybody who’s there, and replace them with your own people?
Sometimes yes — but often no. It’s a whole spectrum from “complete population change” to “everybody stays where they are, but now they answer to a different government.” You might bring in some of your own settlers to establish their own colonies, especially if there’s more land that could be brought under cultivation, or other resources to exploit. You might leave the population untouched but impose your own governors, nobles, and other administration at any level from the village on up. You might leave the existing administration in place, but turn them into your vassals/clients/etc., nominally in charge, but taking their orders from your own state now.
Think back to the treaties essay of Year Nine, and remember that often the way you achieve your desired terms in a treaty is by first defeating the other side in war. Do you want a trade balance that favors your economy over theirs? Free access to their ports? Tribute payments? . . . but I’ll leave that last one for next week, because exactly what gets handed over in tribute is an interesting enough question to deserve unpacking in more detail.
Other military goals do get more arcane, especially once ritual aspects start to move to the forefront. The taking of trophies is rarely the sole or main goal of a war, but it often goes hand-in-hand with the rest. I’m excluding here the general idea of looting, where the point is the accumulation of wealth; instead I mean cases where the symbolic value of the trophy carries significant weight.
Year Nine’s discussion of sacred objects already covered how this can apply to statues of gods and similar relics, but the trophy can be practically anything, so long as it’s sufficiently important. The Stone of Scone, used in the coronation rituals of Scottish kings (so: arguably religious), was taken to England at the end of the thirteenth century as part of a maneuver to establish English authority over Scotland. It remained there for seven hundred years, barring a nationalist attempt to return it in 1950, until it was finally repatriated, in a move with major political implications.
Trophies can also just commemorate victory more generally. The Greeks had a practice of erecting a tropaion, a kind of scarecrow-type figure clad in armor with enemy shields piled around the base, which was originally set up on the battlefield itself. Later the tropaion started to appear instead at sites like Delphi, where Greeks from other regions were more likely to see it (and be intimidated). Romans, carrying this tradition forward under the name tropaeum, displayed their trophies back home in Rome, as proof of a general’s accomplishments and support for his political career. Alternatively, you might destroy a specific trophy, instead of claiming it: Aztec warfare often aimed to burn the temple of the enemy’s patron god, thereby removing a relatively fortified structure and symbolizing their defeat.
Even the conduct of warfare itself can become highly ritualized. Perhaps most famously, there’s the Plains tradition of counting coup, which focuses on showcasing the skill and bravery of the individual warrior: often by touching the enemy in battle without harming anything more than their pride (and then escaping unharmed yourself), but other actions could also count, like touching the enemy’s fortifications or stealing his weapons or horses from his camp. The Aztec flower wars were likewise intended to showcase skill. Although they practiced conventional warfare, as mentioned above, a flower war was a more limited, ritualized version, involving equally matched forces (largely composed of elite warriors, rather than regular citizens) meeting at a pre-arranged place and time, and fighting only with melee weapons.
That type of fighting is mostly going to show up in a society where a warrior’s personal prowess with weapons is considered important. Once you get into styles of warfare where the behavior of the unit is more critical than that of any individual member, it’s likely to fall by the wayside — though perhaps not entirely; there’s reason to think the flower wars were a response to conditions that made all-out mass battles too destructive to engage in.
But it all comes down to the question of what’s important to your military leaders. Stealing an item of religious or political significance can be a better way of showing dominance than just killing people. Taking captives can be more lucrative than leaving their corpses to rot on the battlefield. And occupying seized land with your own people might be a lot more work than just making the current inhabitants follow your orders and pay you money . . .
. . . which is why we’ll talk about tribute next!
